Blog

Seeking asylum in the United States is a significant and often daunting decision, driven by the urgent need for safety from persecution. Understanding the different types of asylum available is crucial for anyone navigating this complex process. If you are looking for a legal way to find safety and start over in the United States, even in extraordinary circumstances – then keep reading. This article provides detailed information about the various forms of asylum in the U.S., the legal grounds upon which they are granted, and the steps involved in applying, empowering you to make informed decisions about your future.

Understanding Asylum in the United States

Asylum is a form of legal protection offered to individuals who cannot return to their home country due to past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution. The United States, adhering to international human rights principles, provides asylum to eligible individuals under specific criteria defined by law.

Eligibility Criteria

To qualify for asylum in the U.S., you must demonstrate that you have suffered persecution or have a well-founded fear of future persecution. The persecution is based on at least one of five protected grounds:

1. Race
2. Religion
3. Nationality
4. Political opinion
5. Membership in a particular social group

Application Deadline

One-year filing rule: You must apply for asylum within one year of your last arrival in the United States unless you can show changed circumstances affecting your eligibility or extraordinary circumstances that caused the delay. 

Procedural Types of Asylum

There are two primary procedural paths for seeking asylum in the U.S.:

1. Affirmative Asylum Process

Who Can Apply?

• Individuals who are physically present in the U.S., regardless of how they arrived or their current immigration status.
• Not currently in removal proceedings.

Application Steps

Step 1: Filing Form I-589: Submit the “Application for Asylum and for Withholding of Removal” to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).

Step 2: Biometric Services Appointment: Attend a scheduled appointment for fingerprinting and background checks.

Step 3: Asylum Interview: Participate in a non-adversarial interview with a USCIS asylum officer who will assess your claim.

Step 4: Decision:

• Approval: You are granted asylum and may apply for a Green Card after one year.
• Referral to Immigration Court: If not granted and you are out of legal status, your case is referred to an immigration judge for removal (deportation) proceedings.

Key Considerations

• Non-Adversarial Setting: The interview is meant to gather information, not to challenge you.
• Legal Representation: While not mandatory, having an attorney is extremely crucial in presenting your case effectively. An experienced attorney can help you prepare your application, gather necessary evidence, and represent you during interviews.
  

2. Defensive Asylum Process

Who Can Apply?

• Individuals who are in removal proceedings before an immigration judge.

Initiation

• Referral from USCIS: After a denied affirmative asylum application.
• Apprehension: Caught by immigration authorities without proper documentation or violating immigration status.

Application Steps

Step 1: Filing Form I-589: Submit your application to the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR).

Step 2: Master Calendar Hearing: A preliminary hearing to schedule the proceedings.

Step 3: Merits Hearing: Present your case before an immigration judge in an adversarial setting.

• Evidence Submission: Provide documentation, witness testimonies, and any other relevant proof.
• Cross-Examination: You may be questioned by a government attorney.

Step 4: Decision:

• Approval: Asylum is granted.
• Denial: May result in removal from the U.S., but you can appeal the decision.

Key Considerations

• Adversarial Process: Unlike the affirmative process, this is more like a court trial.
• Importance of Legal Counsel: Strongly recommended due to the complexity and high stakes. An attorney can navigate the complex legal procedures, advocate on your behalf, and increase the likelihood of a favorable outcome.
  

Grounds for Asylum Claims

To successfully claim asylum, you must establish that persecution occurred or is likely to occur due to one or more of the five protected grounds.

1. Persecution Based on Race

Definition: Persecution due to race involves harm or suffering inflicted upon individuals because of their racial or ethnic identity.

Forms of Persecution

• Violence and Physical Harm: Attacks, torture, or killings targeting specific racial groups.
• Discriminatory Laws: Legislation that restricts rights or imposes penalties based on race.
• Societal Discrimination: Systemic exclusion from education, employment, or healthcare.

Evidence Required

• Personal accounts of incidents.
• Medical records documenting injuries.
• Reports or data showing racial discrimination in your country.

Applicability

• Demonstrate that your race is a central reason for the persecution.
• Show that the government is involved or unable/unwilling to prevent the persecution.

2. Persecution Based on Religion

Definition: Persecution due to religion occurs when individuals are harmed for their religious beliefs, practices, or lack thereof.

Forms of Persecution

• Prohibition of Worship: Banning religious gatherings or practices.
• Forced Conversion: Compulsion to abandon one’s faith or adopt another.
• Punishment for Beliefs: Legal penalties, imprisonment, or torture for religious activities.

Evidence Required

• Documentation of laws restricting religious freedom.
• Affidavits from religious leaders or fellow practitioners.
• Proof of past incidents (arrests, fines, threats).

Applicability

• Must connect the persecution directly to your religious beliefs.
• Highlight any state-sanctioned persecution or societal hostility condoned by the government.

3. Persecution Based on Nationality

Definition: Persecution due to nationality includes harm inflicted because of one’s national origin, citizenship, or ethnic group.

Forms of Persecution

• Ethnic Cleansing: Systematic removal or killing of a national group.
• Statelessness: Denial of citizenship rights, rendering individuals without legal protection.
• Targeted Violence: Attacks against individuals of a particular nationality during conflicts.

Evidence Required

• Country reports highlighting ethnic tensions.
• Personal accounts of discrimination or attacks.
• Proof of denial of basic rights due to nationality.

Applicability

• Establish that your nationality is a primary cause of the persecution.
• Show that protection is not available in your home country.

4. Persecution Based on Political Opinion

Definition: Persecution due to political opinion involves harm because of one’s political beliefs, expressions, or associations.

Forms of Persecution

• Imprisonment or Detention: For participating in political activities or expressing dissent.
• Torture or Abuse: Physical or psychological harm to punish or deter political views.
• Threats and Harassment: Intimidation aimed at silencing political expression.

Evidence Required

• Records of arrests or detentions.
• Membership documentation in political organizations.
• Media articles or reports mentioning your political activities.

Applicability

• Demonstrate that you hold or are perceived to hold a political opinion opposed by the persecutor.
• Show a direct link between your political opinion and the persecution.

5. Membership in a Particular Social Group

Definition: A “particular social group” consists of individuals who share common, immutable characteristics or experiences that are fundamental to their identity.

Forms of Persecution

• Gender-Based Violence: Including domestic abuse, honor killings, or female genital mutilation.
• Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity: Harm due to being LGBTQ+.
• Family or Clan Membership: Targeting due to family associations.
• Former Association: Persecution for previous membership in groups like gangs.

Evidence Required

• Personal statements detailing your experiences.
• Expert affidavits explaining social group dynamics.
• Country conditions reports showing group persecution.

Applicability

• Clearly define the social group and your membership in it.
• Show that the group is recognized as distinct in your society.
• Demonstrate that the persecution is due to your membership in this group.

Additional Forms of Protection

If you do not qualify for asylum, other forms of protection may be applicable to your specific situation.

1. Withholding of Removal

Definition: Prevents the U.S. government from deporting you to a country where your life or freedom would be threatened.

Key Points

• Higher Burden of Proof: Must show that it is “more likely than not” you would face persecution.
• Limited Benefits: Does not lead to permanent residency or allow for family petitions.
• Eligibility: Often used by those who miss the asylum filing deadline or have certain criminal convictions.

2. Protection Under the Convention Against Torture (CAT)

Definition: Protection for individuals who risk being tortured if returned to their home country.

Key Points

• Definition of Torture: Severe pain or suffering inflicted intentionally for purposes like punishment or intimidation.
• No Nexus Required: Unlike asylum, you don’t need to prove persecution based on a protected ground.
• Applicability: Available regardless of criminal history.

Benefits and Limitations

• Protection from Removal: Cannot be deported to the country where you risk torture.
• No Path to Permanent Status: Does not lead to a Green Card or citizenship.
• Regular Reviews: Status may be subject to periodic review.

Special Categories and Considerations

Gender-Based Asylum Claims

Explanation: Recognizes persecution unique to gender, often under “membership in a particular social group.”

Examples

• Domestic Violence: When the state fails to protect victims.
• Forced Marriage: Coercion into marriage without consent.
• Female Genital Mutilation (FGM): Cultural practices causing harm.

Evidence Required

• Personal testimony detailing experiences.
• Medical records or expert reports.
• Country conditions highlighting systemic gender-based violence.

Challenges

• Defining the social group in legal terms.
• Overcoming cultural stigmas to provide detailed accounts.

LGBTQ+ Asylum Claims

Explanation: Individuals persecuted due to sexual orientation or gender identity.

Examples

• Criminalization: Laws punishing same-sex relationships.
• Violence and Harassment: Attacks by government or societal actors.
• Family Rejection: Harm inflicted by family members.

Evidence Required

• Personal narratives.
• Psychological evaluations.
• Reports on treatment of LGBTQ+ individuals in your country.

Challenges

• Proving membership in the social group.
• Cultural barriers in discussing personal matters.

Child-Specific Asylum Claims

Explanation: Children may face unique persecution or be more vulnerable due to age.

Examples

• Forced Recruitment: Into military or rebel groups.
• Child Trafficking: For labor or sexual exploitation.
• Abuse and Neglect: Lack of state protection.

Procedural Protections

• Special Considerations: Unaccompanied minors have specific legal protections.
• Best Interests Principle: Decisions should prioritize the child’s well-being.

Evidence Required

• Statements appropriate for the child’s age.
• Expert testimony on child development.
• Documentation of threats or harm.

Legal Framework Governing Asylum

Understanding the laws that govern asylum can help in preparing a strong application.

International Law

• 1951 Refugee Convention and 1967 Protocol: Establish the definition of a refugee and obligations of non-refoulement.
• Convention Against Torture (CAT): Prohibits the return of individuals to countries where they may face torture.

U.S. Domestic Law

• Immigration and Nationality Act (INA): The primary statute governing immigration, including asylum.
• Refugee Act of 1980: Incorporates international standards into U.S. law, outlining asylum procedures.

Case Law and Precedents

• Court decisions interpret and refine asylum laws.
• Important for understanding how laws apply to specific situations.

Challenges in the Asylum Process

The asylum process can be arduous due to:

• Complex Legal Standards: Navigating statutes, regulations, and case law.
• Evidentiary Burdens: Collecting sufficient proof, especially when fleeing urgently.
• Procedural Hurdles: Meeting deadlines and procedural requirements.
• Emotional Strain: Reliving traumatic experiences during testimonies.

 

Strategies for a Successful Asylum Claim

1. Detailed Personal Statement

• Consistency is Key: Ensure your story is consistent throughout all documents and testimonies.
• Chronological Order: Present events in a clear, logical sequence.
• Specifics Over Generalities: Provide detailed descriptions of incidents.

2. Collecting Supporting Evidence

• Documentation: Medical records, police reports, arrest warrants.
• Country Reports: Human rights reports from credible organizations.
• Witness Statements: Affidavits from individuals familiar with your situation.

3. Legal Representation

• Find an Experienced Attorney: Specializing in asylum and immigration law.
• Pro Bono Services: Seek assistance from organizations offering free legal help if needed.

4. Psychological Evaluations

• Expert Reports: Can substantiate claims of trauma or PTSD resulting from persecution.

5. Stay Informed

• Legal Updates: Laws and policies can change; stay updated on relevant developments.
• Case Status: Regularly check on your application’s progress.

Navigating the asylum process in the United States is a complex journey filled with legal intricacies and emotional challenges. Understanding the different types of asylum and the specific requirements for each can significantly enhance your ability to present a compelling case. While the path may be difficult, the possibility of safety and a new beginning makes it a journey worth undertaking.

Take Action

If you believe you may be eligible for asylum, consider taking the following steps:

• Consult with legal professionals at Benach Collopy:  Our attorneys are among the leading immigration attorneys in the United States who have a specific focus on asylum. An experienced immigration attorney can provide personalized advice and guide you through the process.
• Gather evidence promptly: Start collecting all relevant documents and testimonies as early as possible.
• Prepare thoroughly: Understand each step of the process to reduce surprises and delays.

Your safety and future are important. Taking informed and timely action can make a significant difference in the outcome of your asylum application. Contact us today!