Blog

United States law provides options for people from other countries who need protection from harm in their home nations. One of these options is called affirmative asylum, which is one of the methods for obtaining asylum. This is a legal way for individuals already in the United States, no matter their immigration status, to ask for safety if they fear being harmed.

Key Highlights

• Affirmative asylum is a form of protection available to individuals in the United States who can establish a well-founded fear of persecution in their home country.
• To be eligible, you must meet the definition of a refugee, meaning you are unable or unwilling to return to your home country due to past persecution or a well-founded fear of future persecution.
• The persecution you fear must be based on one of five protected grounds: race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.
• You must file for asylum within one year of your arrival in the U.S, unless you qualify for an exception.
• Seeking legal representation from an experienced immigration attorney can significantly increase your chances of success with your affirmative asylum claim.

What is Affirmative Asylum

Affirmative asylum is a way for people already in the United States to get protection from dangers in their home country. To start the affirmative asylum process, you need to fill out an application with the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). If your application is approved, you could get a green card and stay in the U.S. legally.

Affirmative asylum follows both international and U.S. laws. It is based on the commitment of the United States to protect the rights of refugees. This promise comes from the 1951 Refugee Convention and the 1967 Protocol. These global agreements became part of U.S. law with the Refugee Act of 1980. They help shape the U.S. asylum system today.

The Role of Affirmative Asylum in Protecting Refugees

Asylum is not just a legal status. It is a lifeline for people who are escaping persecution. It’s important to know what makes someone a refugee under U.S. law. A refugee is a person who cannot or does not want to go back to their home country because they have suffered persecution in the past or fear they could be harmed in the future.  Such harm must be on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.

In order to seek asylum, a person must already be in the United States. They could be inside the country or at one of its official ports of entry. How they entered the U.S., whether lawfully or without proper documentation, does not always keep them from applying. What matters most is the fear of persecution involved in their asylum claim and the timing of their applications.

A USCIS officer reviews asylum applications and interviews those seeking asylum. This officer decides if the applicant fits the definition of a refugee and meets other requirements for asylum. The goal is not only to provide refuge. It is also to recognize those who have been through tough times and to give them a fair shot at starting a new life in a country that values human rights.

Eligibility Criteria for Affirmative Asylum

To qualify for affirmative asylum, you must meet certain eligibility criteria established by U.S. law. These rules ensure that asylum is granted to those who genuinely need protection—specifically, individuals who have faced persecution or fear they will face persecution if they return to their home country.

Determining asylum eligibility involves two main steps. First, you must demonstrate that you meet the definition of a refugee under U.S. law. Second, you need to prove that no disqualifying factors under immigration law prevent you from receiving asylum.

Grounds for Seeking Asylum

To be granted asylum, you must prove that your fear of persecution is based on one of five protected grounds: race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.

While most of those categories- such as race and religion- are pretty self-explanatory, a lot of confusion surrounds the meaning of “particular social group.” This includes groups targeted due to inherent traits, shared experiences, or significant aspects of their identity that cannot be changed.  Some successful social groups that we have used include sexual orientation, family ties, battered women and children, and abandoned children.

Persecution can take many forms—it includes not only physical violence but also threats, imprisonment, torture, or severe discrimination. To support your claim, you must provide strong evidence, such as personal accounts, reports on conditions in your home country, and documentation from credible sources.

Necessary Documentation and Evidence

A successful asylum application requires solid evidence to support your claim. Providing the right documents to the immigration authorities is a crucial step in the asylum process.

The required evidence must show “a reasonable possibility of persecution,” meaning you need to convince the asylum officer that there is a significant risk of persecution if you return to your home country. Your evidence should clearly relate to the reasons for your fear of persecution and illustrate your situation effectively.

Supporting documents may include personal statements, witness testimonies, medical records detailing injuries caused by persecution, police reports, news articles, and human rights reports. A well-prepared application that includes comprehensive evidence can significantly improve your chances of a favorable outcome.

Importance of Finding Legal Representation

Navigating immigration law, especially asylum processes, can be challenging—particularly for those fleeing persecution. Finding experienced legal representation can significantly improve your chances of success with an asylum case.

An immigration attorney with expertise in asylum law can provide essential guidance throughout this process. They will evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of your case, assist in gathering crucial documents, and help you prepare for your asylum interview. Having professional legal help ensures that you fully understand the complex requirements of asylum law and that your case is presented effectively.

If your asylum case moves to immigration court, representation becomes even more critical. The Department of Justice’s Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR) oversees these court proceedings, and having a skilled attorney by your side will help protect your rights. Only an experienced lawyer can present your case clearly and professionally, maximizing your chances of a positive outcome.

If you are considering applying for asylum, contact the immigration attorneys at Benach Collopy. As some of the top attorneys in the United States with a keen focus on asylum cases, Benach Collopy is ready to help you through every step of the process. Our expertise and dedication can make all the difference in your journey to safety and legal status.

Steps to Apply for Affirmative Asylum

Applying for affirmative asylum involves several steps, each requiring careful attention to meet USCIS requirements. While each step presents its challenges, understanding them is crucial for navigating the process toward a fair evaluation of your claim and a new beginning in the United States.

Step 1: Filing the Application

Submit Form I-589, Application for Asylum and Withholding of Removal, within one year of your arrival in the U.S. to start the asylum process. Once USCIS receives your completed application, you will receive notices confirming receipt and scheduling your biometric appointment.

Step 2: Fingerprinting and Security Checks

Attend a fingerprinting appointment at your local Application Support Center (ASC). No fingerprinting fee is required for asylum applicants. If your spouse or children are also applying for asylum, they will need to attend this appointment with you.

Step 3: Receiving the Interview Notice

After fingerprinting, USCIS will schedule your asylum interview. You will receive a notice detailing the date, location, and time of the interview.  It may take years before your case is heard by the asylum office.

Step 4: Attending the Interview

Attend the asylum merits interview with a USCIS asylum officer, who will review your application and assess your eligibility. You may bring an attorney, an interpreter (if needed), and any witnesses supporting your case.

Step 5: Awaiting a Decision

The asylum officer will determine if you qualify as a refugee and make a recommendation, which will be reviewed by a supervisory officer. Depending on the outcome, you may need to appear in immigration court for further proceedings. In most cases, USCIS will notify you within two weeks of the interview.

After the Decision: What’s Next?

Once an asylum officer or immigration judge makes a decision on your case, it’s crucial to understand your next steps. A positive outcome brings new opportunities, while a denial does not mean it’s the end of your journey.

The U.S. immigration system is complex, with multiple avenues for relief from removal. Knowing your options can help you navigate this period after the decision.

If Granted Asylum

If your asylum application is approved, you gain protection and several important rights. You can remain in the U.S. without fear of being returned to your home country.

After one year as an asylee, you may be granted lawful permanent resident (LPR) status—commonly known as a “green card”—allowing you to live and work permanently in the U.S. As an LPR, you can also travel internationally (with some restrictions) and petition to bring certain family members to the U.S.

Five years after obtaining your green card, you may apply for U.S. citizenship, completing your journey from asylee to citizen. Asylum offers a new beginning—a chance to rebuild your life in a safe environment.

If Denied Asylum

A denial of asylum by the asylum office can be challenging, but it may not be the end of the road.  You will get anothrer chance to seek asylum defensively in immigration court.  In addition, in immigration there may be other applications you can file.  If the immigration judge rules against you, you have the right to appeal the decision. Your attorney can help determine whether an appeal to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) is appropriate, particularly if there were errors in law or procedure during your hearing.

Even if asylum is denied, you might qualify for withholding of removal, which prevents your return to a country where you may face persecution. While this option offers protection, it generally requires a higher level of proof than asylum.

The appeals process can be difficult, but having experienced legal counsel is invaluable. Your attorney will identify any legal errors and guide you through each step, ensuring the best possible outcome.

Moving Forward with Your Asylum Journey

Seeking affirmative asylum is a significant step toward safety and a new beginning. It requires meeting eligibility requirements, gathering essential documents, and understanding the key differences between affirmative and defensive asylum. Being prepared for every stage of the process—including what to expect after a decision—ensures you can make informed choices about your future.

Although the asylum process can be challenging, having the right legal support can make all the difference. Whether you need guidance on eligibility, help gathering documents, or representation during proceedings, our experienced attorneys are here to help. Contact the skilled immigration attorneys at Benach Collopy today to begin your journey to a secure and stable future.